Comparison
Smith.ai alternatives for contractors (2026): 10 options with prices
What Smith.ai charges for its AI and human receptionists, when a per-call price suits a contractor and when it does not, and ten alternatives with prices from their own pricing pages. CaughtLeads publishes this guide and is one of the ten.
Published
The short answer
CaughtLeads publishes this guide and is one of the alternatives in it. Smith.ai's prices below come from its own pricing pages, and so do the prices of every other service, linked under each table.
Smith.ai offers an AI receptionist and a human receptionist service, both month to month. Some reasons a contractor might compare other options: many short calls, where a per-call price adds up; calls that swing with the weather; or wanting a specific way for each booking to reach their field-service software. Which alternative fits depends on which of those applies to you, and for a shop with few calls Smith.ai's free plan may be the cheapest option of all.
What Smith.ai charges
Smith.ai charges by the call, not by the minute; its AI receptionist page says billing per call means "there's no mystery accounting involved." The AI receptionist has a free plan, a Pro plan and a $500-a-month Enterprise plan that Smith.ai builds and runs for you (Pro's larger levels, 150 and 300 calls, are listed by per-call rate, and Enterprise is a custom build, so both are left out here). Its human receptionists cost more per call.
On terms, its AI receptionist page says the service is month to month and asks for 30 days' notice to cancel. Its human receptionist page lists no setup fees, 10% off a 12-month subscription and a 30-day money-back guarantee for new clients.
Its pricing page names HubSpot, Salesforce, Clio and Zapier among the tools it connects to, and it keeps a directory of integrations. If you run ServiceTitan, Jobber or Housecall Pro, check that directory or ask Smith.ai how a booking reaches your software.
| Smith.ai plan | Price | Past the plan |
|---|---|---|
| AI receptionist, Free | $0 a month, 25 calls | $3 per call |
| AI receptionist, Pro | $150 a month, 75 calls | $2.50 per call |
| Human receptionist, Starter | $300 a month, 30 calls | $11.50 per call |
| Human receptionist, Basic | $810 a month, 90 calls | $10.50 per call |
| Human receptionist, Pro | $2,100 a month, 300 calls | $8.50 per call |
Per call or per minute: what 100 calls cost
Because Smith.ai bills by the call, 100 calls in a month come to $212.50 on its cheapest listed plan for that many, whether the calls are short or long. CaughtLeads charges by the minute instead, each call rounded up to a whole minute, so its bill depends on call length.
With 100 calls of 1 minute, CaughtLeads comes to $61, less than Smith.ai's $212.50. Once calls run past 13 minutes, CaughtLeads costs more and the per-call plan is the better deal. The number of calls matters too: at 43 calls a month or fewer, Smith.ai's free plan costs less than CaughtLeads however short the calls are. Check your phone bill for your call count and average call length before you choose.
| Each call lasts | Smith.ai AI receptionist, 100 calls | CaughtLeads, 100 calls |
|---|---|---|
| 1 minute | $212.50 | $61 |
| 3 minutes | $212.50 | $85 |
| 5 minutes | $212.50 | $109 |
| 10 minutes | $212.50 | $169 |
| 15 minutes | $212.50 | $229 |
The same 100 calls on every service
Smith.ai is not the only per-call option, and per-minute is not always cheapest. Here is 100 calls of 3 minutes on every service whose pricing page gives enough to work it out, each on the cheapest listed plan that covers the month. Upfirst costs less than CaughtLeads for this month.
| Service | Answered by | Cheapest listed plan that covers 100 calls of 3 minutes | Month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfirst | AI | Premium (90 calls) plus 10 calls at $1 | $69.95 |
| CaughtLeads | AI | $49 plus 300 minutes at $0.12 | $85 |
| My AI Front Desk | AI | Business-in-a-Box, 200 minutes and 1,000 credits (240 minutes) plus 60 minutes at $0.25 | $114 |
| OnCrew | AI | Starter (150 minutes) plus 150 minutes at $0.49 | $122.50 |
| Dialzara | AI | Business Pro (220 minutes) plus 80 minutes at $0.45 | $135 |
| NextPhone | AI | Pro plan, unlimited inbound calls | $199 |
| Smith.ai (AI receptionist) | AI | Pro (75 calls) plus 25 calls at $2.50 | $212.50 |
| PATLive | Live people | Monthly (300 minutes) | $479 |
| Smith.ai (human receptionist) | Live people | Basic (90 calls) plus 10 calls at $10.50 | $915 |
10 alternatives, by starting price
AI services first, then live answering services, each from the lowest starting price. A low starting price can include very few calls, so read the last column too.
| Service | Answered by | Starts at | How the bill grows |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfirst | AI | $24.95/mo | 30 calls included, then $1.50 per call |
| Dialzara | AI | $29/mo | 60 minutes included, then $0.48 per minute |
| CaughtLeads | AI | $49/mo | $0.12 per voice minute (each call rounded up to a whole minute) and $0.03 per text segment; no minutes or calls bundled |
| OnCrew | AI | $49/mo | 150 minutes included, then $0.49 per minute |
| Rosie | AI | $49/mo | 250 minutes included; 1,000 minutes for $149/mo |
| Goodcall | AI | $79/mo | Plans at $79, $129 and $299 a month |
| My AI Front Desk | AI | $99/mo | 200 minutes included, then credits at 25 a minute ($0.25); $79/mo billed yearly |
| NextPhone | AI | $199/mo | Flat, unlimited inbound calls |
| PATLive | Live people | $49/mo | $49/mo plus $2.99 per minute pay-as-you-go; 50 minutes for $99/mo, then $2.29 per minute |
| Ruby | Live people | $250/mo | 50 minutes included; 100 minutes for $395/mo |
Which kind of alternative fits which shop
Few, steady calls: a plan with a bundle of calls or minutes (Upfirst, Dialzara, OnCrew, Rosie, My AI Front Desk) is usually the cheapest, as long as you pick the bundle that fits. Smith.ai's own free plan belongs on that list too.
Calls that swing with the weather: a plan with a small base and a charge only for the minutes answered (CaughtLeads: $49 a month plus $0.12 a minute) avoids paying for a big bundle in a quiet month. A storm week costs more because more calls are answered.
Always busy: a flat-rate plan (NextPhone) gives one bill however many inbound calls you get.
A person on every call: a live answering service (PATLive, Ruby, or Smith.ai's own human receptionists) does that, usually at several times the price per minute of the AI plans in this guide.
Where CaughtLeads fits, and where it doesn't
CaughtLeads fits an owner-run or small-team home-services business (roughly 1 to 15 trucks) whose calls are mostly short and come in bursts. It answers, books the job, and then shows which booked appointments actually held, so you see work that happened rather than work that was promised.
It is not the right pick if you want a person on every call, if you get few calls or long ones (where a per-call price is cheaper), or if you need a direct ServiceTitan or Jobber connection: CaughtLeads reaches both only through your own Zapier, and sends bookings to Housecall Pro directly (in beta) as leads in its Job Inbox.
The service names on this page are trademarks of their owners, used only to identify them. CaughtLeads is not affiliated with any of them.
Questions contractors ask
- What is the best Smith.ai alternative for a contractor?
- It depends on your calls. For a few steady calls, a bundle plan such as Upfirst or Dialzara is usually cheapest. For calls that swing with the seasons, a per-minute plan such as CaughtLeads follows the volume. For one flat bill, NextPhone. For a person on every call, PATLive or Ruby. Each one's starting price is on its own pricing page, and this guide lists them side by side.
- Is Smith.ai's AI receptionist free?
- Its pricing page lists a free plan of 25 calls a month, then $3 a call. Its Pro plan is $150 a month for 75 calls, then $2.50 a call.
- Is CaughtLeads cheaper than Smith.ai?
- It depends on how many calls you get and how long they last, because Smith.ai charges by the call and CaughtLeads by the minute. At 100 calls a month of 3 minutes each, CaughtLeads comes to $85 before texts, less than Smith.ai's $212.50. At 100 calls, once calls run past 13 minutes Smith.ai costs less. At 43 calls a month or fewer, Smith.ai's free plan costs less whatever the call length.
- Do I need a contract?
- Neither needs one. Smith.ai's AI receptionist is month to month with 30 days' notice to cancel; its human receptionist plans list no setup fees and 10% off for 12 months. CaughtLeads is month to month with no setup fee, or 15% / 30% off the monthly base on a 3- or 12-month plan.
- Is there a free trial?
- CaughtLeads lets you build and talk to your receptionist in the browser for free with no card. The free trial on a real phone line needs a card on file, charges nothing at checkout, and lasts 7 days or 100 voice minutes, whichever comes first. Smith.ai's AI receptionist has a free plan, and its human receptionist plans come with a 30-day money-back guarantee for new clients.
Build your own in two minutes
Try it free: we'll fine-tune an AI receptionist to your business, then test it on a real call.
Try it free