All resources

Comparison

Best AI receptionists and answering services for contractors (2026): 11 compared with prices

Nine AI receptionists and two live answering services that HVAC, plumbing, roofing and electrical contractors look at, with each one's starting price from its own pricing page, how the bill grows, and which pricing model fits which call pattern. CaughtLeads publishes this guide and is one of the eleven.

Published · Updated

The short answer

CaughtLeads publishes this guide and is one of the eleven options in it. The prices of the other ten come from their own pricing pages, linked under each table.

There is no single best AI receptionist for every contractor. The right one depends mostly on how many calls you get, how much that number swings with the seasons, and whether you want software or a person to answer.

If you get a steady, small number of calls, a plan that includes a set number of calls or minutes is usually the cheapest. If your calls swing with the weather (storm weeks, the first hot or cold week of the year), a plan that charges only for the minutes answered avoids paying for a big bundle in a quiet month. If you want a human on every call, a live answering service does that, at several times the price per minute. If you want one flat bill no matter what, there are flat-rate plans too.

Prices compared

Every price below was read on the company's own pricing page. AI services come first, then live answering services, each listed from the lowest starting price. A low starting price can include very few calls, so read the last column too.

ServiceAnswered byStarts atHow the bill grows
Smith.ai (AI receptionist)AI$025 calls free, then $3 per call; Pro $150/mo for 75 calls, then $2.50 per call
UpfirstAI$24.95/mo30 calls included, then $1.50 per call
DialzaraAI$29/mo60 minutes included, then $0.48 per minute
CaughtLeadsAI$49/mo$0.12 per voice minute (each call rounded up to a whole minute) and $0.03 per text segment; no minutes or calls bundled
OnCrewAI$49/mo150 minutes included, then $0.49 per minute
RosieAI$49/mo250 minutes included; 1,000 minutes for $149/mo
GoodcallAI$79/moPlans at $79, $129 and $299 a month
My AI Front DeskAI$99/mo200 minutes included, then credits at 25 a minute ($0.25); $79/mo billed yearly
NextPhoneAI$199/moFlat, unlimited inbound calls
PATLiveLive people$49/mo$49/mo plus $2.99 per minute pay-as-you-go; 50 minutes for $99/mo, then $2.29 per minute
RubyLive people$250/mo50 minutes included; 100 minutes for $395/mo
Starting prices from each company's own pricing page, checked November 2, 2026. AI services first, then live answering services, each from the lowest starting price; equal prices in alphabetical order. Prices change, so check the company's page before you buy. Sources: Smith.ai (AI receptionist) · Upfirst · Dialzara · CaughtLeads · OnCrew · Rosie · Goodcall · My AI Front Desk · NextPhone · PATLive · Ruby

What a 100-call month costs

Starting prices hide how the bill grows. Here is the same month on every service in this comparison whose pricing page gives enough to work it out without guessing: 100 calls of 3 minutes each, so 300 minutes, and no add-ons, on the cheapest plan each one lists for it. CaughtLeads bills each call in whole minutes, rounded up.

On this month CaughtLeads costs more than Upfirst's call bundle. The order depends on call length, because Upfirst charges by the call and CaughtLeads by the minute: at 1 minute a call, 100 calls cost CaughtLeads $61, less than Upfirst's $69.95; at 5 minutes a call they cost $109, more than it.

ServiceAnswered byCheapest listed plan that covers 100 calls of 3 minutesMonth
UpfirstAIPremium (90 calls) plus 10 calls at $1$69.95
CaughtLeadsAI$49 plus 300 minutes at $0.12$85
My AI Front DeskAIBusiness-in-a-Box, 200 minutes and 1,000 credits (240 minutes) plus 60 minutes at $0.25$114
OnCrewAIStarter (150 minutes) plus 150 minutes at $0.49$122.50
DialzaraAIBusiness Pro (220 minutes) plus 80 minutes at $0.45$135
NextPhoneAIPro plan, unlimited inbound calls$199
Smith.ai (AI receptionist)AIPro (75 calls) plus 25 calls at $2.50$212.50
PATLiveLive peopleMonthly (300 minutes)$479
Worked from each company's own pricing page, read on November 2, 2026, using the cheapest plan it lists for this month, and sorted by the result. Left out because their pages do not give enough to work out this month without guessing: Rosie, Ruby, Goodcall. CaughtLeads bills each call in whole minutes, rounded up; texts are extra at $0.03 per text segment and start once your carrier registration is approved. Prices change, so check the company's page before you buy. Sources: Upfirst · CaughtLeads · My AI Front Desk · OnCrew · Dialzara · NextPhone · Smith.ai (AI receptionist) · PATLive

The three ways these services charge

Per call (Smith.ai): you pay for each call answered, whatever its length. That works out well when calls are long and costs more when you get many short ones.

A bundle of calls or minutes each month (Upfirst, Dialzara, OnCrew, Rosie, My AI Front Desk, PATLive, Ruby): you pay for the bundle whether you use it or not, then a per-call or per-minute rate past it. Good when your volume is steady and you can pick the bundle that fits.

Per minute with nothing bundled (CaughtLeads): a fixed $49 a month, then the minutes answered, each call rounded up to a whole minute. A quiet month costs little and a storm week costs more, so this model suits shops whose calls swing. A flat-rate plan (NextPhone) is the opposite: one bill however many inbound calls come in, which suits a shop that is always busy.

What to ask any of them before you sign

Does it book into my calendar or my job software, or only take a message? Ask which software, and whether it books directly or through a connector like Zapier.

What does it do if a caller smells gas or sees fire, and what does it do with an urgent repair like no heat or a burst pipe? Can it transfer a call to my on-call person?

How does it text my customers, and is that texting registered with the phone carriers? Texting customers in the US needs carrier registration, and unregistered texts get blocked.

Does it tell callers they are talking to an AI and that the call may be recorded? Is there a contract or a setup fee, and is there a free trial on a real phone line?

Where CaughtLeads fits, and where it doesn't

CaughtLeads fits an owner-run or small-team home-services business (roughly 1 to 15 trucks) whose calls come in bursts: after storms, in the first hot or cold week, in the evening. It answers, books the job, and then shows which booked appointments actually held, so you see work that happened rather than work that was promised.

It is not the right pick if you want a person on every call (a live service such as PATLive or Ruby does that), if your calls are long and a per-call plan works out cheaper for you, or if you need a direct ServiceTitan or Jobber connection: CaughtLeads reaches both only through your own Zapier, and sends bookings to Housecall Pro directly (in beta) as leads in its Job Inbox.

The service names on this page are trademarks of their owners, used only to identify them. CaughtLeads is not affiliated with any of them.

Questions contractors ask

What is the cheapest AI receptionist for a small contractor?
Smith.ai's AI receptionist has a free tier: 25 calls a month, then $3 a call. Among paid plans, Upfirst starts at $24.95 a month for 30 calls and Dialzara at $29 for 60 minutes; CaughtLeads starts at $49 plus the minutes answered, and OnCrew and Rosie at $49. The table above lists all eleven by starting price. What you actually pay depends on your calls: for 100 calls of 3 minutes, Upfirst came to $69.95 and CaughtLeads to $85, before texts.
How much does an AI answering service cost for a home service contractor?
Starting prices for the AI services in the table run from Smith.ai's free 25-call tier to NextPhone's $199 a month for unlimited inbound calls. The bill then depends on how each one charges and on your calls: for 100 calls of 3 minutes, the worked month above came to $69.95 on Upfirst, $85 on CaughtLeads (before texts), $135 on Dialzara, $199 on NextPhone and $212.50 on Smith.ai's AI receptionist. Live answering services cost more: the same month is $479 on PATLive.
What is a virtual receptionist for a home services business?
A receptionist who answers your business line without sitting in your office: either a person at a live answering service, such as PATLive or Ruby, or an AI receptionist, software that answers, answers questions from your business facts and books the appointment. For a home-services business, ask the same three things of either: does it book into your calendar or job software, what does it do with an emergency call, and how does it charge.
Is an AI receptionist cheaper than an answering service?
Usually, by several times per minute. PATLive's pay-as-you-go plan is $49 a month plus $2.99 a minute and Ruby starts at $250 a month for 50 minutes, while the minute-based AI plans above charge under $1 a minute. A live service is worth the difference when you want a human voice on every call.
Does an AI receptionist work with Jobber, ServiceTitan or Housecall Pro?
Some do, in different ways, so ask each one exactly how. CaughtLeads sends each booking to Housecall Pro directly as a lead in its Job Inbox (in beta), and to Jobber and ServiceTitan through your own Zapier, where a ServiceTitan booking waits on the Call Booking screen for your team to accept.
Can an AI receptionist handle emergency calls?
Two kinds of call need different answers. If a caller smells gas, has a carbon monoxide alarm going off, or sees fire, a good one tells them to leave the building and call 911 from outside, and ends the call so they are not on the phone inside. For an urgent repair like no heat or a burst pipe, it takes the details, books the earliest slot you have opened, promises a call back you can keep, or transfers the call to your on-call person. It cannot send a technician by itself.
Is there a free trial?
Check each company's page. CaughtLeads lets you build and talk to your receptionist in the browser for free with no card; the trial on a real phone line needs a card on file, charges nothing at checkout, and lasts 7 days or 100 voice minutes, whichever comes first.

Build your own in two minutes

Try it free: we'll fine-tune an AI receptionist to your business, then test it on a real call.

Try it free